Back in the day, before I had graduated grade school, and before microbrews had taken over the American beer market, there were beers that had a case of mistaken identity. One, for example, was Killian's Irish Red. Everyone's favorite Irish beer other than Guinness, was known as a slightly smokey Irish Red Lager,not ale as the original recipe calls for, that you could always count on when you didn't want a German beer. But wait a second, Killian's was made in Ireland right? Wrong! Coors brewed it based on an old recipe.
So today, I see a beer that sounds interesting: McSorley's Ale, "brewed with the Irish Spirit." Okay, so I understand that this flat out means it ain't brewed there but come on. On the packaging, it says New York, USA. On the bottle it says Wilkes-Barre, PA. So what's going on here? Well... McSorley's is an Ale House that has been in business in Manhattan since 1854. It has a wonderful storied history that was chronicled in 1943 by New Yorker Magazine writer Joseph Mitchell. McSorley's Beer Ale has been made since the inception of the 'Old Ale House,' as far as I could tell. More after the jump!
Now, the bar (kind of a tourist trap) still serves the brew but you can't really classify it as an American classic. It is, but unlike Budweiser or any of the famous American blue collar beers still brewed today, this thing has switched so many hands that I don't know what to call it (it's now brewed by Pabst). The beer is less Irish than it thinks it is. The taste is like a hoppier version of a cream ale. Thankfully, it isn't as creamy as Genny Cream, but that still doesn't necessarily save it. It used to be manufactured as McSorley's Cream Stock Ale, but is now simply know as McSorley's. I'm not exactly sure how a beer can become famous and recognized when the name on it doesn't refer to the brewer but the only bar that ever served the stuff.
Is it good? You bet! It has a bit of the macrophlegm that you get from cheaply produced beers like High Life and PBR, but it has much more depth in flavor than those. But they are session beers and this isn't.


Read more!